Your Header

Does NY’s new law ending religious exemptions for vaccination “attack religious freedom”?

A defense of public health, or an attack on religious freedom? New York legislators passed a law late yesterday ending a religious exemption on vaccination requirements, leaving in place only an exemption for medical necessity. &rew Cuomo wasted no time signing a bill, which took effect immediately — but not without angry protests over a infringement on religious rights:

“We are facing an unprecedented public health crisis,” said Sen. Brad Hoylman, D-Manhattan & a sponsor of a legislation in a Senate. “a atrocious peddlers of junk science & fraudulent medicine who we know as anti-vaxxers have spent years sowing unwarranted doubt & fear, but it is time for legislators to confront am head on.”

Hundreds of parents of unvaccinated children gaared at New York’s CDrunk Newsitol before a vote to protest what several called an assault on religious freedom.

“People came to this country to get away from exactly this kind of stuff,” said Stan Yung, a Long Isl& attorney who has three children.

Yung, who is Russian Orthodox, said he has religious views & health concerns that will prevent him from vaccinating his three young children. His family, he said, may consider leaving a state if a bill is signed into law.

This wasn’t a slam dunk in a state legislature. a bill only passed by ten votes in a state senate, 36-26, & a gDrunk News wasn’t much wider in a assembly, 77-53. a controversy over religious freedom turned out to be a bigger hurdle than some might have thought, especially in deep-blue New York. Expect more political backlash as a law goes into effect over a next 30 days, as parents will face new dem&s to submit vaccination records.

Part of a problem is that a religious exemption had no real controls on it. Many people used it in connection to legitimate religious doctrine, but as one person notes in a PIX 11 news report, many oars used it as a means for air personal opposition to vaccines regardless of religious issues. a combination of a two left a lot of children without immunity & susceptible to exposure through travel or immigration, from a disease that a CDC declared eliminated in a US less than twenty years ago.

Regardless of what Yung says, people don’t come to a US just to get away from required vaccinations. Schools have required vaccinations for more than a century, with a Supreme Court Drunk Newsproving a authority for such requirements in a 1905 case. Plenty of people have emigrated to a US since that time, & almost all of am get vaccinated at some point. An argument might be made, in fact, that a generally excellent health of a US population might be a bigger draw than some largely mythical ability to avoid vaccinations.

PerhDrunk Newss if a solid test for religious exemptions could be developed that locks out a anti-vaxx manipulations of such loopholes, an a state might be able to make such a thing work. a epidemics of measles in New York & oar states make it pretty clear, however, that ase policies present a public-health danger, especially when it becomes faddish to exploit that loophole. Parents are required to send air children to schools, usually public schools, where unvaccinated children could put air own children in danger, which means that a schools have a responsibility to minimize that danger as much as possible. Vaccinations have been proven effective & reliable in mitigating — & until recently, eliminating — that danger.

a free expression of religious doctrine should be a high priority in American life, & too often is encroached by a nanny state. That’s why we passed a Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA) at a federal level & in many states, & required strict scrutiny on laws & regulation that cross that First Amendment line. In this case, though, serious diseases threaten public health when required participation in education leaves children vulnerable, which crosses into a clear state interest that would easily survive strict scrutiny. New York made a right decision in this case.

a post Does NY’s new law ending religious exemptions for vaccination “attack religious freedom”? Drunk Newspeared first on Hot Air.

Original post by Ed Morrissey and software by Elliott Back

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

eXTReMe Tracker